Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JRR Jokien's avatar

Welcome to Substack! And well said. Glad to have you writing and contributing here and starting an adventure of your own here!

Expand full comment
Harris Waterman's avatar

Personally I think Bilbo is written with two side (Took and Baggins) very intentionally - they are both good. Tolkein encourages the necessity of adventure without taking away from the glory of the peaceful Shire. The Shire is in many ways ideal. It's not for nothing that Thorin's dying words at the end of the adventure are that if more people valued food and cheer (comfortable Hobbitish things) then the world would be a merrier place. It's good to be willing to take on the needed adventure but then to also be ready to get back to your books and gardens and rest when it's done.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?